The Analytic Observer
Newsletter of the Chicago Psychoanalytic Society
VOLUME 8, NUMBER 2
June 2000
Contents
The President's Message by Phil Lebovitz, M.D.
Director's Column by Jerry Winer, M.D.
Coming Events!
President's Message by Phil Lebovitz, M.D.
This academic year has been a stimulating year
for the Society. The Program Committee has done an excellent job of
identifying, and arranging for, high quality papers; the format was
modified to have only one discussant in order to facilitate a more
lively interaction between the presenter and the attendees. The Pritzker
Auditorium at Northwestern's new hospital has proved to be a setting
that also promotes contact between the audience and the speaker. Many of
next year's presentations have been arranged, also.
The biennial conference of March 2000
accomplished its goals of beginning an exploration of the clinical
issues facing us when we treat lesbians and gay men, as well as
establishing a basis for clinical discussions with members of the gay
and lesbian mental health community. The attendance was very good. The
Society attempted to include pharmaceutical companies and to obtain
funding from them for the conference. This, however, was only a partial
benefit. The Conference planning committee learned that specific
guidelines are essential for working with these companies; if the
Society decides to approach them again in the future, terms, such as
kind of exposure and cost for the opportunity, will have to be clearly
presented and accepted prior to the conference.
Over the summer I am asking the members to think
over an issue about the categories of membership that has come to the
attention of the executive committee in the last few months. A proposal
to broaden the Society's full membership category to include any
applicant who has graduated from a recognized psychoanalytic institute,
even if the institute is not accredited by the American Psychoanalytic
Association, was briefly discussed at the April business meeting. The
attendance at the business meeting was too low to consider the
possibility of a definitive resolution of this issue at that meeting.
The agreement reached by those at the meeting was to inform the
membership of this idea through this column and through a mailing; the
November business meeting would then be the time to reach a decision
about this proposal.
The Society has an application for membership
which is used when one seeks to become a member. The application
inquires about the applicant's training and requires the applicant to
sign a statement that he/she will abide by the American's principles of
ethics and will abide by the Society's provision of the Psychoanalyst
Assistance Committee. The application is reviewed by the membership
chair/committee, is then brought to the executive committee; and then
the applicant's name is circulated among the entire membership for
comments. The applicant's credentials must meet basic standards in order
to reach the point of his/her name being circulated.
The question which most of us raise is what is
gained by broadening our membership in this manner; alternatively, the
challenge might be raised whether this would "dilute" or lower our
standards. Although this will most likely be the focus of the discussion
of this proposal, a reasonable case can be made that by allowing
graduates of other institutes to be part of our membership, we have more
opportunity to influence the standards of other parts of an analytic
community and to become the umbrella organization which could function
as a local consortium of the kind in which the American participates in
its effort to establish certification across psychoanalytic groups.
Finally, I have deep appreciation for Hank Evans
as he completes his year as past president, for Dick Herron as he
completes his term as treasurer, for Steve Flagel as he finishes as
secretary, to the program committee ( Dan Busch, George Moraitis, Brenda
Solomon, Sallee Jenkins, Joe Cronin), and the biennial conference
committee (Jim Fisch, Dottie Jeffries, Bert Cohler, Bob Fajardo, Marty
Fine, Dennis Shelby, Hank Evans, Virginia Saft).
Director's Column by Jerry Winer, M.D.
Summer is fast approaching and we look forward
to a more relaxed pace at the Institute after an unusually busy year. To
celebrate the end of the academic year, this year's graduation party
will be held at The Standard Club. Congratulations to the graduates:
Linda Garrity, Neal Spira, Robert Welker, Michael Grover (Child and
Adult), and Colin Pereira-Webber (Child and Adult). During this past
year, we have also welcomed Caryle Perlman, Steve Stern, Leo Weinstein,
Colin Pereira-Webber, and Neal Spira to the Institute faculty.
The American Psychoanalytic Association held its
Annual Meeting in Chicago during May, and the Institute and Society
co-hosted a cocktail party on Tuesday, May 9th. Over 200 guests marveled
at the wonderful facilities of the Institute and were treated to
excellent food and drink. Thank you to Brenda and David Solomon and
Caryle Perlman who co-chaired the local arrangements committee.
After almost a full year of planning, the
Institute's very ambitious Conference on Youth and Violence took place
over the weekend of May 12-13. Although registration was lower than we
had originally anticipated, by all accounts the conference was a
resounding success. Over 200 registrants representing schools, law
enforcement, social service agencies, the legal system, clergy, health
care providers, and state and local government, heard presentations by
local and national experts from a variety of disciplines. The Public
Forum provided an opportunity for members of the American Psychoanalytic
Association and the lay public to attend a portion of the conference on
Friday. This "town meeting" was moderated by Chicago's own John
Callaway, with panelists Mark Smaller, Elijah Anderson from the
University of Pennsylvania, Steven Marans from the Yale Child Study
Center and the Western New England Institute, Douglas MacDonald,
Assistant Chief of Police for New Haven, CT, and Paul Vallas, Chief
Executive Officer of the Chicago Public Schools. The conference would
not have occurred without the "blood, sweat and tears" of a very
industrious committee, under the chairmanship of Bob Galatzer-Levy. Pat
Rueckheim, who devoted countless hours to organizing the program and
preparing the very distinctive brochure, is in the process of
constructing a report to be presented to the conference's lead sponsor,
The Elizabeth Morse Charitable Trust and other supporters and interested
parties.
The first Thomas James Pappadis, M.D. Prize was
awarded to Paul David Meyer for his paper entitled "Freud and the Human
Sciences." Mr. Meyer just graduated from the University of Chicago. The
paper will appear in the next volume of The Annual of Psychoanalysis,
which is a special volume on "Freud and the Modern World." Contributors
to the volume include members of our own psychoanalytic community, as
well as Peter Loewenberg, Glen Gabbard, and Marcia Cavell. The volume of
The Annual will also be published in a special paperback edition to be
offered for sale at the bookstore of The Field Museum when the Library
of Congress Freud exhibit "Conflict and Culture" comes there in October
2001.
I am very proud to report that the Barr-Harris
Children's Grief Center has met the matching grant of $50,000 for this
year. The Barr Foundation and Irving Harris each agreed to double their
support from $25,000 to $50,000 if the Institute was successful in
raising an equal amount. With a little more effort, and hopefully the
expertise of a Development Director, maybe we can up the ante to
$75,000!!!
The Board of Trustees elected new officers who
are already taking on fresh initiatives for our organization. The new
officers are: Eva Lichtenberg, chair; Mara Blumenthal, vice-chair;
Harvey Kallick, treasurer; and Henry Evans, secretary. They are actively
recruiting new members, and I am very excited to report that Renee
Gelman, M.D. will be joining the Board. Renee maintains an apartment
here and visits approximately every six weeks, so she will be able to
attend Board meetings and many of the Institute activities and social
functions.
In our ongoing efforts to reach out to other
schools, agencies, and cultural institutions, the Institute will jointly
sponsor a half/day conference with the C. G. Jung Institute on The
Interpretation of Dreams: 2000. This will be held on October 28th at the
Jung Institute in Evanston. Bob Fajardo chairs the committee meeting
with representatives of the Jung Institute to plan this program. Bob
Galatzer-Levy and Harry Trosman will make presentations, as will two
members of the faculty of the Jung Institute. A brochure is being
prepared and will be distributed at the end of the summer.
To date, seven candidates have been accepted for
the fall class of the Core Program. The Adult Psychoanalytic
Psychotherapy Program has received 7 applications for its fall class and
expects several more. A number of past students of the Psychotherapy
Program have gone on to candidacy in the Core Program. Congratulations
to Jim Fisch who was recently appointed Director of this very successful
program.
Victoria Lautman recently interviewed me about
our Institute and psychoanalysis for "City 2000." This is an effort to
record in sound and visually the city of Chicago in the year 2000 for
the future.
A very fine summer to everyone.
Editor...........................Richard I.
Herron, M.D.
Assistant to the Editor....Ms. Eva Sandberg
Coming Events:
Chicago Psychoanalytic Society Meetings
Pritzker Auditorium, Northwestern Memorial
Hospital Feinberg Pavillion
OPEN TO ALL MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY
June 27, 2000
Presenter: Arnold Goldberg, M.D.
Gaps, Barriers and Splits:
The Psychoanalytic Search for Connection
Discussant: TBA
Click Here for ABSTRACT
Gaps, Barriers and Splits:
The Psychoanalytic Search for Connection
June 27, 2000
Northwestern Dental School
240 E. Huron Rm 3380
7:00 pm
Presenter: Arnold Goldberg, M.D.
Abstract: This paper explores the pictorial imagery that
is often used to explain the mind and mental processes. In particular it
examines the gap that is said to exist between neurophysiologic and
psychologic phenomena, the barrier said to explain the separation of
unconscious from preconscious and conscious ideation and the split said
to constitute the essentials of disavowal and denial. In each of these
visual renditions, the claim is made that there is a logical
contradiction, which stems from linear thinking. In addition the paper
aims to suggest to the reader that the proper appreciation of these
erroneous images might remove present-day futile efforts to pursue
solutions based upon these images.
|